London's Pulse: Medical Officer of Health reports 1848-1972

View report page

Richmond upon Thames 1971

[Report of the Medical Officer of Health for Richmond]

This page requires JavaScript

The Clean Air (Suspension of Smoke Control — Richmond upon Thames) Order, 1970, suspended the following Orders until 31st March, 1971:—

Smoke Control Order.No. of Premises in Area.
The Barnes No. 1 Smoke Control Order, 19601815
The Barnes No. 2 Smoke Control Order, 19611482
The Barnes No. 3 Smoke Control Order, 19621673
The Barnes No. 4 Smoke Control Order, 1963187
The Richmond (Surrey) No. 1 Smoke Control Order, 1959341
The Richmond (Surrey) No. 2 Smoke Control Order, 19601603
The Richmond (Surrey) No. 3 Smoke Control Order, 19611989
The Richmond (Surrey) No. 4 Smoke Control Order, 19621553
The Richmond (Surrey) No. 5 Smoke Control Order, 19632558
The Twickenham No. 1 Smoke Control Order, 19611918
The Twickenham No. 2 Smoke Control Order, 19623815
The Twickenham No. 3 Smoke Control Order, 19624640
Total23574

It was in some ways an embarrassment that these Orders were suspended by the
Secretary of State. It arose because the solid fuel manufacturers and producers had
failed to meet the demand. The fuel merchants serving the area had found it impossible
to forecast the likely short-fall in the supplies of solid smokeless fuel but fortunately in
the event the shortage was small and little bituminous coal was burnt. This was mainly
due to the large majority of consumers demanding smokeless fuels in preference to coal.
Indeed the greatest proportion of this coal was taken up by old aged pensioners because
of its initial low cost when compared with premium cokes such as Coalite and Rexco,
although the cost of heat produced is the most expensive. This is illustrated in the table
to follow.
In July 1971, the Secretary of State for the Environment assured all local authorities
that supplies of solid smokeless fuels seemed likely to meet consumer demand indicating
that it was not expected that there would be any further need to suspend smoke control
orders. No supply difficulties were experienced until the miners' strike at the end of the
year and at the time of writing supplies of solid smokeless fuels are not seriously affected.
When discussing heating costs and the pensioners' preference for coal it is interesting
to compare the figures in the following table which are based on the appliance efficiencies
and annual fuel consumption set out in the 1963 White Paper "Domestic Fuel Supplies
and the Clean Air Policy." Gas coke is no longer sold retail in the borough.

The Estimated Average Weekly Cost of Room Heating Using SO cwts of Bituminous Coal per Annum compared with Alternate Fuels.

FuelAppliance1966196919701971
CoalStool and Fret£0.64£0.67£0.82£1.06
(Gas Coke)Improved open fire£0.59£0.63£0.91
(Coalite)Improved open fire£0.90
Hard CokeOpenable Room heater£0.40£0.44£0.58£0.60
GasGas room heater£0.50£0.55£0.55£0.60
ElectricElectric Fire£0.78£0.90£0.89£1.00
Electric (off Peak)Electric Storage Heater£0.40£0.43£0.38£0.57
ParaffinFixed Flued Heater£0.41£0.41£0.42£0.49