Hints from the Health Department. Leaflet from the archive of the Society of Medical Officers of Health. Credit: Wellcome Collection, London
[Report of the Medical Officer of Health for Heston and Isleworth]
This page requires JavaScript
29
The Autumn of 1931 saw the culmination of a fight for
justice in the matter of the adoption of a child who was subsequently
certified as mentally defective.
The matter is so important that it is necessary, I think, to
set the facts out in some detail.
The child—a girl now 12 years old—was adopted at the age
of 4 years 11 months by a childless couple of the very best working
class type. The first time I saw the child after she entered school
I told them she was mentally abnormal, and that something should
be done with regard to returning the child to its parents, or to
the National Children Adoption Association, through whose
machinery the child had been adopted.
I got into touch with one of the members of the Adoption
Association, and finally was given an interview by the solicitor
to the Association. The attitude adopted by him may be
gathered from the following letter.
" The Contract entered into by the adopting parents
can in no sense be taken to be conditional upon the opinion
of the Association's Medical Adviser proving correct.
Obviously, such a course would be most impracticable as
you, in your position as Medical Officer of Health, will be
the first to appreciate.
" The fact of the child being now found to be abnormal
does not affect the adopting parents' Agreement, and after
one month has expired from the date of the adopting
parents taking possession of the child, the adopting parents
surely have no right, and indeed cannot expect the Association
to again assume responsibility for any child adopted
through their good offices. The adopting parents must deal
with the child as they would were it their own."
The point I raised with the Association was that they had
not provided the adopting parents with what they had asked
for, viz. a normal child. After considerable correspondence on
the matter I wrote to Lady Astor, who at that time was deeply
interested in the Act. The following is an' extract from
the letter.
"I want to draw your attention to a difficulty—.and
that a serious one—in the Adoption Act. Whilst wholeheartedly
supporting the principles involved, there is just
one point that has been overlooked, and the consequences
are so serious that I feel something ought to be done, and
the best way I can illustrate the position is by giving details
of the case I have under my care at the present time.