View report page

73
In such cases the suggested duty would be impossible of
performance by the Medical Officer of Health. It would
take up too much space to deal exhaustively with the subject,
but I may further remark, speaking now from my experience in
this Parish, that, practically, all deaths returned as "uncertified "
are referred to the Coroner, and registration takes place only
after the Coroner's decision that inquisition is unnecessary.
The preliminary inquiry by the Coroner's officer is not satisfactory;
and it is probable that in many of the cases in which
inquests would be held under existing circumstances, an inquiry
by an expert—e.g., a Medical Officer of Health—would save
the time of the Coroner, and of persons liable to serve as
jurymen, as well as some expense to the county, if his decision
that an inquest was unnecessary were accepted. In these
circumstances, the Medical Officer would become, practically,
the "Coroner's Officer," as indeed the St. James's Vestry propose.
If suitably remunerated for the task, he might reasonably be
authorized to inquire, in the first instance, into the causes of
uncertified deaths; and to certify in proper cases; referring
those from violence, or otherwise involving suspicion of foul
play, to the Coroner. Any such change would require
legislation to give it effect; but it may be doubted whether
the legislature would entrust to any individual powers of such
an exceptional nature.* In the case of deaths registered as
"not certified," after reference to the Coroner, it cannot be
doubted that an inquiry and report by a Medical Officer of
Health would be more satisfactory than that by a Coroner's
Officer. Presumably, the deaths "not certified" in lone and
mountainous districts, are not even referred to a Coroner.
In some of the manufacturing towns there is much so-called
"medical" practice by unregistered persons, upon whose information,
probably, many deaths are registered: registration
being required by law, which medical certification is not—
excepting in the case of persons who had been duly attended
*It may be mentioned that the subject of certification of deaths, and cognate
matters, has been referred to a Select Committee which is now sitting, May, 189a.